I was going to title it as ‘ClearType sucks’ but anyway.
ClearType uses a technique named subpixel rendering that absolutely sucks – at least for me. Say for example i have some black text on white background then the subpixel rendering will make some adjacent pixels have some colors. Take a example, Consolas, a font that works only with ClearType:
That just looks painful for my eyes, i see every colored pixel in something that should had been only black and white (or gray at least) – it’s just friggin painful. If you don’t notice it (well, I might see better than you) look here:
And I’m not just running on crap hardware – I think a Dell 2407WPF-HC is good enough !
I’ve also tried to tune the ClearType a bit and it still looks like crap.
2 Comments
I think it’s the eye that matters, not the display. I’m also in the minority that cannot stand ClearType because of the color halo around the letters. The halo is less annoying for me on darker backgrounds, but on white it is pure hell.
Thankfully, on Linux, Pango can turn on anti-aliasing independently of sub-pixel rendering, so fonts can be smoothed without the color halo. Also, pango allows different settings for different fonts, so you can have some fonts smoothed (or even sub-pixel rendered) and some not. For instance, I configure the Vista fonts on Linux to be smoothed by auto-hinter, while the pre-Vista MS fonts (Arial etc.) to be hinted using the bytecode interpreter. This way each font performs the way it was designed, except that I leave out the halo.
Adobe has IMO a better smoothing technology implemented in it’s products. No color halo. You can turn in on as described here: http://blogs.adobe.com/alshamma/2007/05/font_smoothing_in_reader_acrob.html. Small font becomes much more legible. There is a minor downside: letter positioning is altered a bit. So, if you want to see the letters positioned *exactly* as they will be printed, you want to use the default “monitor” setting instead of the LCD one.
Totally agree. The colour bleed is absolutely awful. If I could get XP style fonts on Windows 7 (ie: crisp & pixelated, with no smoothing), I’d upgrade in heartbeat.The font rendering in Windows 7 is the only thing keeping me from switching.